16 Questions to Ask Your Marketing Agency Every Month

Most monthly agency reports look good. Traffic is up, impressions are up, the charts point the right way. Yet many business owners finish the call with no idea whether the money they spent came back, what the agency changed, or what should happen next month.
The fix is usually not a better dashboard. It's a better question. We asked founders, CEOs, marketing leaders and agency owners, through a Connectively roundtable, which one question they ask a marketing agency every month and what changed once they started asking it. These are the 16 answers we found most useful. Several come from people who run agencies themselves and say which question they wish every client asked them.
Got last month's agency report handy? Bring it to a free 20-minute Report X-Ray and we'll show you which of these 16 questions it can't answer.
The 16 questions at a glance
Question to ask your agency | What it reveals | Contributor |
How much did it cost to get a paying customer, and how much came back? | Payback, not traffic | Mariia Grachova, Loona Agency |
What did this make me after what I spent? | Net profit after spend and fulfillment | Cody Jensen, Searchbloom |
Which conversions are you optimizing for, and are they real new customers? | Whether bidding chases repeat or fake conversions | Brandon Kidd, DeltaV Digital |
How many of last month's signups are still active today? | Lead quality by channel | Ace Zhuo, TradingFXVPS |
Which search terms paid for our results, and did this month's changes touch them? | Risk to your profitable core | Dr. Igor Ivitskiy, Doctor Ads |
What did you stop doing this month, and why? | Whether the agency reads its own data | Rick Elmore, Simply Noted |
What should we stop doing, and what's the data behind it? | Activities with no link to leads or sales | Fahad Khan, Ubuy Qatar |
What did you spend money on this month that you'd cut tomorrow? | Hidden waste | Christopher Coussons, Visionary Marketing |
What would you keep if I cut the budget in half? | Which channels the agency truly believes in | Will Yang, Chronicle Technology |
What did you try that didn't work? | Whether anyone is experimenting | Derek Wild, Listening.com |
What did you change this month, and what were the numbers before? | Cause and effect | Daniel Goh, RankAISearch |
Which URLs, by name, and what is still not measured? | Reporting blind spots | Ayoub Rhillane, RHILLANE Marketing Digital |
What did we learn this month that changes what we do next month? | Decisions, not activity | Kruno Sulić, Cliprise |
Which customer objection did our marketing reduce? | Lead quality and sales readiness | Jason Hennessey, Hennessey Digital |
What are you hearing that the dashboard can't show? | Context behind the numbers | Dawood Bukhari, Digital Web Solutions |
Which inputs this month moved which outputs? | The link between work and results | Aishwarya Lohi, Equip |
1. Ask what a customer cost and what came back
Mariia Grachova, Co-Founder & CEO at Loona Agency, says rising traffic charts lead to the question every SEO dreads: how much did I make from this? Her agency now reports the cost of a paying customer against the revenue it brought in. For one roofing client, impressions grew while click-through rate fell, and either number alone would have misled the owner. Call tracking per location and first-touch data in the CRM showed leads up 61% and a 10x return in high season.
Cody Jensen, CEO & Founder at Searchbloom, keeps it even simpler: revenue in, minus what you spent, minus what it costs to fulfill. He calls rankings a poor metric, because buyers now research in Google, ChatGPT and Perplexity and then search the brand name, so a dashboard can record a lost click where you actually won the decision.
Brandon Kidd, VP Operations at DeltaV Digital, adds a check on the conversions themselves. One healthcare client's Google Ads counted existing patients calling about appointments as conversions. Once the CRM fed only verified new patients back into bidding, cost per new patient fell from $549 to $129 within a year and new patient bookings rose more than fivefold on 19% more spend.
Ace Zhuo, CEO | Sales and Marketing, Tech & Finance Expert at TradingFXVPS, asks how many of last month's signups are still active 30 days later. The cheapest ad placement turned out to bring signups that never used the product. Two "top performing" channels were dropped after six weeks because fewer than 20% of their signups stayed.
Dr. Igor Ivitskiy PhD, Founder at Doctor Ads, makes the question defensive: which search terms actually paid for our results, and did this month's changes touch them? In the accounts he audits, the median account gets 62% of its conversions from the top 1% of search terms by spend, so a blended average can hide damage to the queries that pay the bills.
2. Ask what they cut and what failed
Activity is easy to inflate, says Rick Elmore, Founder & CEO at Simply Noted. Asking what the agency stopped doing shows whether it is reading the data. His paid media agency admitted in month two that a high click-through campaign was producing almost no demos, cut it and moved the budget to retargeting. If the answer is "nothing" three months in a row, he treats it as a red flag.
Fahad Khan, Digital Marketing Manager at Ubuy Qatar, found that 9 of 22 regular activities in a 31-page monthly report had no link to leads or sales. After cutting 8 of them and moving about $4,200 a month to the three most effective, cost per lead fell from $86 to $54 and qualified leads grew 33%.
Christopher Coussons, Director at Visionary Marketing, who runs accounts on the agency side, wants clients to ask what he would cut tomorrow. It forces him to defend every line of spend instead of touring the dashboard. Will Yang, Head of Growth, Co-founder at Chronicle Technology, asks a sharper version: what would you keep if I cut the budget in half? His agency named a couple of channels at once and struggled to defend the rest. After cutting the rest, new customer numbers held steady on a much smaller spend.
Derek Wild, CEO & Founder at Listening.com, asks what the agency tried that didn't work. A report with zero failures, he argues, means nobody tried anything risky. Once failed tests stopped being a problem, the agency brought real experiments, and the reports became more honest overall.
3. Ask what changed and what isn't measured
Daniel Goh, Chief Marketing Officer at RankAISearch, asks for a log of every change made that month with the numbers before it. His team once found a plugin adding hidden text and oversized images to pages while the monthly reports said things were improving. They now log date, page, change and Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools baselines, and make one change at a time.
Ayoub Rhillane, CEO at RHILLANE Marketing Digital, asks which URLs, by name, and what is still not measured. A report that lists affected URLs by urgency can go to a developer the same morning. And blind spots, like one locale in his own setup that had no health score, usually come from how a tool was configured months earlier, not from anyone hiding them.
Kruno Sulić, Founder & SaaS Product Builder at Cliprise, asks what the agency learned this month that changes what happens next month. A good review, in his view, ends with what worked, what failed and what changes because of it.
4. Ask about buyers and context
Jason Hennessey, CEO at Hennessey Digital, asks which customer objection the marketing reduced. When lead volume rose but close rates stayed flat, the agency began studying sales notes and reviews, and briefs became objection maps instead of keyword lists.
Dawood Bukhari, CEO at Digital Web Solutions, asks what the account team is hearing that the dashboard can't show, such as a new executive or a team under pressure to justify spend. Those signals let a partner adjust the plan before confidence drops.
Aishwarya Lohi, Head of Marketing at Equip, matches the question to the agency's job. For SEO: which inputs this month moved which outputs? For design: what's the version you'd show us if we hadn't briefed you?
Questions to ask a marketing agency before you hire it
The monthly questions only work if the relationship is set up for them. Before you sign, ask:
How will you measure success, and which numbers will we see every month?
Can you show us a sample monthly report, with the client's name removed?
Who will work on our account day to day, and how often will we talk?
What tracking do you need from us, such as CRM access or call tracking, to report on customers and revenue?
Who owns the ad accounts, analytics and data if we part ways?
What will you do in the first 90 days, and how will we know it's working?
If an agency can't answer these clearly before the contract, it won't answer the monthly questions either. Our guide on how to choose a web design agency covers the same ground for website projects.
Our take: a monthly agency review checklist
We're an agency too, so these are questions we expect clients to ask us. If you only bring a few to your next monthly review, we'd pick these:
What did a new customer cost this month, and what did those customers bring in? Agree on the target cost per customer up front.
Which conversions count, and how do you know they're new customers rather than repeat visits, calls or spam?
What did you change this month, on which pages or campaigns, and what were the numbers before?
What did you stop, and what failed? A report with no failures is a warning sign, not a good month.
What would you keep if the budget were cut in half, and what would you cut tomorrow?
What did we learn that changes next month's plan?
Not sure your report would pass? Bring it to a call and we'll go through it with you live, question by question, and show you what's missing. Just your numbers and straight answers.
If your reports can't answer these yet, ask for the tracking that makes them possible: call tracking, CRM source data and a simple change log. Our marketing strategy development work starts with exactly this. For paid search, our guide to Google Ads KPIs covers which numbers to put in front of your agency.
Related reading: Outsourced SEO: When It Pays Off (and When It Doesn't) and 13 Ways to Lower Your Client Acquisition Costs.
Frequently asked questions
What should a monthly marketing agency report include?
At minimum: what you spent, what it cost to win a new customer, how much revenue those customers brought in, what the agency changed and what it stopped, and what it plans to do next month. Clicks and impressions are useful context, not the result.
How often should you review your marketing agency's performance?
Monthly is the right rhythm for most businesses: often enough to cut waste quickly, long enough for tests to produce real data. Save bigger decisions about budget or strategy for a quarterly review.
What are red flags in a marketing agency report?
A report full of wins with no failed tests, nothing the agency stopped doing, conversions that can't be tied to real customers, and no list of what changed during the month. If the agency can't name anything it would cut, it probably hasn't looked hard enough.
How do you know if your marketing agency is worth it?
Compare what you paid, in fees and ad spend, with the profit from the customers the agency brought in. If the report can't get you to that number, ask for the tracking that makes it possible, such as call tracking and CRM source data.
Interview us like you'd interview your agency. Bring the toughest question on this list to a 20-minute call and see how we answer it about your own account.
The roundtable: our contributors in their own words
These are the full answers our contributors gave for this roundtable, word for word.
Calculate Acquisition Payback
The question I'd want every client to ask us each month is simple: how much did it cost to get a paying customer this month, and how much money came back from those customers?
I started pushing for it because of the conversation every SEO specialist dreads. You show a client a nicely rising organic traffic chart, they look at it and ask, "Okay, and how much did I make from this?" If calls aren't tracked and the CRM doesn't know where a lead came from, you have no answer.
Once that question became our monthly standard, the reports changed completely. For Rapid Roofing, a premium roofer on Long Island with an average job of about $28,000, impressions grew 422% while CTR fell from 0.17% to 0.08%. Reported on their own, both numbers would have misled the owner. Because every Google Business Profile location had its own tracking number and the first touch was carried into the CRM next to the deal amount, we could show him that leads grew 61% and ROMI reached 10x in high season.
It changed our first sales call too. We now start by asking what the client's margin is and how much they can afford to pay for a new customer, so the monthly question always has a target to be measured against.
Mariia Grachova, Co-Founder & CEO, Loona Agency
Measure Net Profit
I'm Cody C. Jensen, founder and CEO of Searchbloom, a digital marketing agency. I've run Searchbloom since 2014. I sit on the agency side of the table. Let me flip it. If I hired an agency, I'd ask one question each month: what did this make me after what I spent?
Not clicks. Not rankings. Rankings are the single most stupid metric, because what I see in Google isn't what you see. Rank tracking is wrong by definition. Clicks used to line up with revenue too. The link broke. Somebody shopping for pearl earrings now browses Google, ChatGPT, and Perplexity, picks a brand, then searches the brand name. A dashboard calls that a lost click. You actually won the decision.
So keep the math simple. Revenue in, minus what you spent, minus what it costs to fulfill. Call it your net. Forms, calls, and purchases make money. Clicks don't. If the monthly report can't get you to that number, ask why. ROI isn't only dollars, either. It covers your time and your effort. Are you getting more out than you put in? Whole question, right there.
Cody Jensen, CEO & Founder, Searchbloom
Verify First-Time Conversions
I run an agency, so here's the answer from the other side of the table. The question I want every client to ask us each month is: "Which conversions are you optimizing for, and how do you know they're real new customers?" We started pushing for it after taking over a 15-location OBGYN practice's Google Ads. Their campaigns counted every conversion, including existing patients calling to check appointment times. New patients cost $549 each. We connected their CRM to Google Ads so bidding only targeted verified new patients. Within 12 months, cost per new patient fell to $129, and new patient bookings went from 234 to 1,268 a year on just 19% more spend. Once clients ask that question, monthly reviews stop being about clicks and start being about customers.
Brandon Kidd, VP Operations, DeltaV Digital
Track Thirty-Day Server Retention
"Of last month's signups how many still have a live server running today? (i.e. MT4/MT5 terminal connected & invoicing for server usage, 30 days on from sign-up)".
After the quarter finished, with agency numbers looking great but actual revenue barely increasing, I kept asking "how many of last month's signups still have a live server running today?". It turned out the majority of signups from one very cheap ad spot (far cheaper than the others we were testing) had signed up, gotten a server provisioned and then never logged in to any trading app on that server. The server had been paid for for a second month by the time I found out about this.
This simple question very quickly became my opening question for the monthly review meetings. The data from the servers was piped into the agencies' tracking software so they could very quickly see the true performance of the different channels. Two of the previously 'top performing' channels were subsequently culled from the rotation after only 6 weeks as their 30 day survival rate was less than 20%. Slow trading forums and high priced listings on sites such as EA developer communities with a high 30 day survival rate ended up becoming the bulk of our spend as reported signups went down dramatically but we had a huge increase in paying customers and a decrease in support calls per customer as the new customers were people who had a full understanding of what a VPS was for.
What you want to optimize is what the agency is left to report. And if all you care about is the number of signups till the end of the signup page then all you're paying the agency to do is fill up a leaking bucket, faster and faster.
Ace Zhuo, CEO | Sales and Marketing, Tech & Finance Expert, TradingFXVPS
Protect Profitable Search Terms
The question I tell every business owner to ask their agency each month is this: which search terms actually paid for our results, and did anything you changed this month touch them? I started pushing clients to ask it because audits kept turning up the same thing. The agency reported a healthy blended cost per acquisition while new tests, broader match types or budget shifts were quietly squeezing the small group of queries that produce the sales. In the ad accounts I audit, the median account gets 62% of its conversions from just the top 1% of search terms by spend, because buying intent piles up on a few brand and near exact queries. A report built on averages therefore mostly describes the part of the account that brings in a minority of the results. Once owners start asking it, the agency checks that core before it opens the dashboard, so cuts and experiments land on the long tail instead of on the queries that pay the bills. The counterintuitive part is that the most useful monthly question is defensive rather than about growth, and protecting that core is exactly what lets an account test aggressively everywhere else.
Dr. Igor Ivitskiy PhD, Founder, Doctor Ads
Cut What Fails
The one question I ask every agency we work with each month is: "What did you stop doing this month, and why?" Most agency reports are lists of activity, more posts, more ads, more keywords. Activity is easy to inflate. Asking what they stopped forces them to show they are reading the data and killing what is not working instead of padding the scope. At Simply Noted, this question changed our relationship with a paid media agency. In month two they admitted a campaign with great click-through was producing almost no demo bookings, and they cut it and moved budget to retargeting past website visitors. Cost per booked demo dropped significantly the following month. It also builds trust. An agency that confidently tells you what they cut is one that is managing toward your revenue, not their retainer. If the answer is "nothing" three months in a row, that is a red flag.
Rick Elmore, Founder & CEO, Simply Noted
Eliminate Unproductive Activities
Every single month, my question is always: What should we stop doing, and what's the data behind it? Very few reports from any agencies include not only what was added in terms of posts, keywords, and advertising but also what should have been eliminated.
I came up with the idea after finding out that in our agency's monthly report, there were 31 pages of analysis, but no one knew how many activities generated revenue. After some research, we found that out of 22 regular activities we used, 9 of them were not linked to leads or sales in any way.
During the next two quarters, we eliminated 8 of those activities, while allocating the funds - around $4,200 per month - to the three most effective. Cost per lead decreased from $86 to $54, the number of qualified leads grew by 33%, the monthly report became 5 pages long, and our meetings became only 35 minutes long.
The lesson: ask what to stop, not just what to start.
Fahad Khan, Digital Marketing Manager, Ubuy Qatar
Identify Wasteful Spend
The question I want every client to ask me each month is a blunt one: what did you spend money on this month that you would cut tomorrow? I run the accounts on the other side of that relationship, and when a client asks it, they get better work out of me, because it forces me to defend every line of spend instead of walking them through a report full of clicks and impressions.
I push for it because most monthly reporting hides waste. My own research found that 79% of B2B marketers are making budget decisions on incomplete or inaccurate data (https://visionary-marketing.co.uk/blog/b2b-marketing-attribution-data-2026). A tidy dashboard rarely shows the search terms that burned budget with no enquiries, or the campaign that got a budget increase just as its returns started to fall.
Once that question is on the agenda, the meeting changes shape. It stops being a tour of the numbers and turns into a short list of things to switch off, things to test and things to leave alone. It also gives the client a simple way to hold me to account without needing to understand bidding strategies. If I can't name something I would cut, that tells them something too, and it usually means I haven't looked hard enough at the account that month.
Christopher Coussons, Director, Visionary Marketing
Rank Channels Under Constraints
At the edtech company I co-founded, I asked our agency the same question every month. I wanted to know what they'd keep if I cut the budget in half. Agencies never liked hearing it.
But the answer told me which channels they actually believed in and which ones they ran because the plan said so. I ran sales and marketing on a tight budget, and I didn't have room for channels that only looked busy.
The first time I asked, the agency named a couple of channels right away and struggled to defend the rest. So we cut the rest, and our new customer count held steady on a much smaller spend.
In my experience, agencies spread money across every channel because more activity looks like more work. Asking the half-budget question each month forced ours to rank what actually brought in buyers. If you run lean with an agency, ask it before the next invoice.
Will Yang, Head of Growth, Co-founder, Chronicle Technology
Reward Bold Experiments
Every month, I ask our agency: "What did you try that didn't work?"
I started asking because the monthly reports were always good. Impressions up, clicks up, cost per click down, everything green. But our actual signups weren't moving the way those charts said they should. At some point I realized that a report with zero failures doesn't mean everything worked. It means nobody tried anything risky, or they did and left it out.
I don't blame agencies for this. They're paid to keep clients happy, and the easiest way to do that is to show steady wins. That pushes them toward safe tweaks: adjust the bid, refresh the ad image, run the same playbook again. Over time you end up paying for upkeep and calling it growth.
Asking about failures changes what they're rewarded for. The first couple of months, the answers were thin and a bit nervous. Then they started bringing real experiments: a new audience nobody had tried, a strange headline, a channel we'd written off. Most of them flopped, which was fine. A few worked well enough to change where we spend money.
The less obvious benefit was that the reports got more honest overall. Once the agency knew a failed test wouldn't get them in trouble, they also stopped dressing up the numbers. In one month, they flagged that a campaign that looked great on paper was bringing in visitors who never converted. We cut it. Under the old way of reporting, it might have kept running for a year.
My advice is to judge your agency by how much they're learning, not only by results. If they never report a failure, you aren't seeing the whole picture.
Derek Wild, CEO & Founder, Listening.com
Log Modifications Against Baselines
"Report on changes made this month and previous numbers."
So I asked the question on the audit of RankAISearch, an SEO Search Engine Optimization plugin that was adding hidden "missing headings" text to pages on the site. A page that normally was a few KB in size was 2MB because of three 570KB images for icons on the page. And none of us even noticed the extra images or the hidden text. And the monthly reports were saying that things were getting better and better on the site, but we had no idea what changes had been made to the site or if they had even had a positive effect.
Now our agency documents all of the changes in a simple log of date, page, change and baseline numbers from Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools before the change. We try to make one change at a time and wait a few weeks to see if it had any impact.
By reducing the amount of information we receive in our reports, we have become more honest in what we are reporting. We can now confidently determine whether a ranking increase came from new content, schema or a change to a template. For example, we recently fixed up an icon on a particular page and it dropped in size from about 570KB per icon to approximately 330KB per icon. We can also catch tools that are modifying the site in ways that we did not intend. I don't claim that this site will necessarily have better rankings, but if 10 things were to change at once then you would learn nothing from the reports and you would be paying for guesses.
One free thing you can do today is to ask your agency for a list of changes that they did last month with dates. If they cannot provide this to you then you will know that they are not able to provide you with any value.
Daniel Goh, Chief Marketing Officer, RankAISearch
Name Unmeasured URLs
I run an agency, so I ask it of my own reporting first: which URLs, by name, and what is still not measured?
Both halves earn their place. Any report can say a site got healthier. A report that names every affected URL per issue, grouped by how urgent each one is, can be handed to a developer the same morning. Our weekly technical report for our own site is built that way on purpose: it lists every affected URL per issue, grouped as Fix First, Important, Hygiene and Monitor, one PDF per locale.
The second half of the question came out of our own setup. We run four locales. Three of them sit on clean prefix projects in the audit tool. The Morocco one did not, and the tool's own notes say what that costs: "INTERIM: filtered to root URLs (other locales excluded). No health score until a dedicated project exists." So Morocco was the one locale where nobody could quote a score, and a reader who only ever saw a headline number would not have known it was missing.
That is why I ask what is not measured. Reporting blind spots are rarely hidden on purpose. They come from how a tool was configured months earlier, and they survive because nobody says the question out loud.
What the question forces, on both sides of the table: a URL list instead of a trend line, a named owner for the gap, and the specific fix that closes it. In our case the fix is a dedicated crawl project for the root locale with exclude rules for the other prefixes, which is what gives Morocco a real health score and week-over-week deltas like the others.
If a score is all you ever get, you cannot tell a site that improved from a report that quietly stopped looking at part of it.
Turn Insights Into Action
The one question I ask a marketing agency every month is: What did we learn this month that changes what we do next month?
I started asking that because too many agency updates sound busy without being decision-ready. You get impressions, clicks, CTR, maybe even a nice-looking dashboard, but you still do not know what should be scaled, paused, rewritten, retargeted, or cut. As a founder working across SaaS, content, and digital acquisition, I learned that the real value of an agency is not just execution. It is turning spend and activity into clear next actions.
Once I made that my recurring question, the quality of conversations improved fast. Instead of vague reporting, I got sharper answers like: short-form video hooks are outperforming static creative for lower-funnel traffic, branded search is rising because top-of-funnel content is finally assisting conversions, or a landing page message is attracting clicks but filtering out the wrong users. Those are useful because they lead to decisions.
What changed most was accountability. The agency had to connect performance to a hypothesis, and then connect that hypothesis to the next test. If they could not explain what was learned, it usually meant we were collecting metrics instead of building a system.
A close second question is: What should we stop doing right now? That one prevents teams from protecting underperforming channels just because they have history behind them.
For me, a good monthly agency review should end with three things: what worked, what failed, and what changes because of it. If I leave the call with that level of clarity, the agency is helping the business move forward. If not, they are mostly reporting activity.
Kruno Sulić, Founder & SaaS Product Builder, Cliprise
Map Buyer Objections
The question I ask each month is, "Which customer objection did our marketing reduce?" Search and content are often judged before the sale is understood. Yet the most durable demand comes from removing uncertainty, especially in decisions involving risk, cost, or trust.
I started asking after lead volume rose while close rates stayed flat. The missing piece was better prequalification. It pushes agencies to study sales notes, reviews, and hesitation language. Briefs became objection maps, not keyword lists. Campaigns became less noisy, sales received better prepared buyers, and leadership could see whether marketing created demand or rented attention for growth.
Surface Relationship Signals
The question is, "What are you hearing in conversations that the dashboard cannot show?" It gives account leads permission to bring forward weak signals. In engagements, relationship intelligence is more predictive than an aggregate.
I started asking after noticing that renewals were at risk despite results on paper. The missing context was organizational, including a new executive, budget logic, or a team under pressure to justify spend. Capturing those signals changed how priorities were framed and when stakeholders were involved. It made discussions less reactive. A partner that understands the client's reality can adjust the operating plan before confidence erodes, not after a renewal conversation becomes defensive.
Match Metrics to Agency Scope
The one question depends on what the agency is for. We've worked with agencies on website design, events, social media and SEO, and the question differs for each.
For SEO it's structured: "Which inputs this month moved which outputs?" Backlinks built, pages published, fixes shipped on one side; rankings, traffic and demo requests on the other. I started asking because early reports listed activity without tying it to results. Once the agency had to draw the line between the two, the work shifted toward what actually moved numbers and away from what filled a slide.
For design it's open-ended: "What's the version you'd show us if we hadn't briefed you?" The first drafts were safe and looked like every other B2B SaaS site. Asking for the unconventional option every month pushed them to explore, and we ended up with a design system we're happy with, one that works across digital and physical, from the website to event booths and merch.
Aishwarya Lohi, Head of Marketing, Equip
Want reports that answer these questions?
SYMVOLT has worked with more than 200 partners over 14 years. We report on customers and revenue, not just clicks, and we're happy to walk you through how we'd measure your marketing.
Pick a time that suits you. It's a 20-minute Google Meet, and you keep every note we make.




Comments