How to Build a Loyalty Program That Feels Personal
Updated: Oct 26
Points don't create loyalty. Feeling recognized does. Most loyalty programs reward spending with a discount, which customers like but rarely remember, and which trains them to wait for the next deal. The programs that actually keep customers coming back make people feel known.
That expectation is now mainstream. McKinsey research found that 71% of consumers expect companies to deliver personalized interactions, and 76% get frustrated when this doesn't happen. We asked founders and marketing leaders how they build loyalty that feels personal. Here are their eight approaches, and how we'd turn them into a program.
Loyalty program ideas at a glance
Idea | Why it works | Effort |
|---|---|---|
Perks that complete a purchase | Rewards what the customer cares about, not just spend | Medium |
Personal video messages | Puts a real face on the brand | Low |
Recognize engagement and milestones | Rewards reviews, referrals and anniversaries, not only purchases | Medium |
Remember the story behind the purchase | Makes customers feel known | Low |
Talk to customers before designing anything | Builds the program around real motivations | Low |
Let members choose their benefits | Different customers value different things | Medium |
Surprise gifts | Creates moments people share | Low to medium |
Quizzes that reveal intent | Tailors rewards to what each customer wants | Medium |
1. Tailor perks to complement purchases
Anh Ly, Founder and CEO of Mim Concept, rewards customers for what they care about, not just how much they spend. When someone who bought a dining table spends a few months browsing lighting or chairs, they get an offer to complete the room. Modest perks, such as early access, a material upgrade or free shipping on a matching piece, work better than "10% off", which teaches people to wait for discounts.
2. Record personal video messages
Adam Boucher, Head of Marketing at Turtle Strength, includes a card with every order that customers scan to watch a personalized video: a thank-you and a tip on using their gear. Customers reply, share it and come back.
Our take: short personal videos cost almost nothing to make and stand out because so few brands do them. Handwritten notes work the same way for many businesses.
3. Reward engagement and recognize milestones
Max Shak, Founder and CEO of nerD AI, moved a retail client from "spend more, get more" to "engage more, get recognized". Members were rewarded for reviews, referrals and replying to emails, with early access, personal thank-yous and anniversary recognition. The client saw more repeat purchases and a stronger sense of community.
4. Remember stories and honor occasions
Tom Daube, President of Washington Diamond, keeps notes from every appointment: the story, the partner's name, the occasion. The team then reaches out at anniversaries. For online stores, he suggests a simple "What's the occasion?" field at checkout.
5. Listen first, then build around customers
Yates Jarvis, Founder and Principal of 2 Visions, warns against starting with a loyalty-program template. Spend a week talking to customers to understand what moves them to commit more. He finds most businesses guess first, and guess wrong.
6. Let members choose their benefit track
Mark Bietz, CMO of Halloween Costumes, lets members choose how they want to be rewarded when they join: convenience, discovery or early access, with the option to switch. Examples include early access to new releases, bonus points during key shopping periods, and planning help with curated recommendations.
7. Surprise members with thoughtful gifts
Maria Bakatsiuk, Founder and CMO of Maramio, describes a jewelry brand that quietly added personalized silk scarves to loyalty members' orders. Customers shared them without being asked, and repeat purchases rose. The gift doesn't need to be expensive. It needs to feel considered.
8. Use quizzes to understand intent
Madeline Jack, Chief Client and Operations Officer at Blink Agency, uses interactive quizzes and guided tools before purchase to learn what each customer values, then offers rewards and "insider" access that match.
How to build a loyalty program, step by step
Talk to your best customers. Ask why they buy again and what would make them buy more often. Look for patterns before designing anything.
Decide what you'll reward. Spending, yes, but also reviews, referrals, social shares and anniversaries.
Choose rewards that fit your brand. Early access, upgrades, exclusive products, service perks and recognition often beat discounts, and they protect your margins.
Add personal touches. A thank-you video, a handwritten note or a remembered occasion turns a transaction into a relationship.
Collect useful data, with consent. Purchase history, preferences and occasions let you personalize. Ask only for what you'll use.
Communicate through channels you own. Email and SMS keep members informed without depending on social algorithms.
Measure what matters. Repeat purchase rate, time between orders, customer lifetime value and referral volume tell you whether the program pays for itself.
Common loyalty program mistakes
Making the program so complicated that customers can't explain it
Relying only on discounts, which erodes margins and attracts deal-seekers
Setting reward thresholds so high that most members never reach them
Collecting data and never using it to personalize
Launching and then never updating the program
The roundtable: our contributors in their own words
These are the full answers our contributors gave for this roundtable, word for word.
Tailor Perks to Complement Purchases
I'm Anh Ly, founder and CEO of Mim Concept, a premium furniture brand I design and run in Canada. One of the most personal ways to build loyalty is to reward customers based on what they care about, not just how much they spend. In furniture retail, that means recognizing taste, timing, and buying behavior. We've seen a better response when we treat loyalty as a design relationship instead of a points system. For example, if a customer orders a dining table, then spends three to four months browsing lighting or chairs, I would trigger a tailored loyalty offer around completing the room rather than sending a generic discount. Even a modest perk like early access to a small release, a material upgrade, or complimentary shipping on a matching piece can feel more personal than 10 percent off. In my experience, generic rewards train people to wait for deals. Personal rewards show you were paying attention, and that is what builds loyalty.
Anh Ly, Founder & CEO, Mim Concept
Record Personalized Video Messages
Most loyalty programs feel fake, but a personalised video makes customers feel seen instantly.
We run a fast growing fitness eCommerce brand selling weight lifting belts, lifting straps and gym gear for people serious about strength training. With every order, we include a Snapcard, it's like a greeting card you scan to watch a personalised video message recorded just for that customer.
I record a quick thank you and share a tip on how to use their gear. Customers message back, share it, and come back again because it feels personal, not like another transaction.
Adam Boucher, Head of Marketing, Turtle Strength
Send handwritten thank-you notes
The most personal loyalty program I have ever seen in action is also the simplest: a handwritten thank you note after the first purchase.
At Simply Noted, we practice what we preach. Every new customer gets a handwritten note within 48 hours of their first order. Not a printed card. Not an email. A real pen on paper note that says something specific about their order. Our robots write with actual ballpoint pens so it looks and feels like a human sat down and wrote it.
The impact on repeat purchase rates was immediate. Customers who received a handwritten note after their first order were 40% more likely to place a second order within 90 days compared to those who just got the standard email sequence. And they spent more on that second order.
For ecommerce and retail businesses looking to replicate this, the playbook is straightforward. Segment your first time buyers. Within 24 to 48 hours of their purchase, trigger a handwritten note that references what they bought and includes a personal touch. The note shows up in their mailbox 3 to 5 days later, right when the excitement of their purchase might be fading.
The handwritten envelope gets a 99% open rate because people physically cannot ignore real handwriting in their mail. Compare that to a loyalty email sitting in a promotions tab with a 15% open rate. The cost per note runs $3 to $5 and the ROI on retention alone pays for itself within one repeat purchase.
Rick Elmore, CEO, Simply Noted
Reward Engagement and Recognize Milestones
One thing I've learned working with e-commerce brands is that most loyalty programs are built around transactions, not relationships. Points, discounts, tiers—they work to a degree, but they rarely feel personal because they treat every customer the same.
The shift happens when you start rewarding behavior, not just purchases.
I remember working with a retail client who had a pretty standard points system, but engagement was flat. What we realized was their most valuable customers weren't just the ones spending the most—they were the ones engaging with the brand in different ways. They were leaving thoughtful reviews, referring friends, even responding to emails. None of that was being acknowledged.
So we rethought the program to recognize those moments. Instead of just "spend more, get more," it became "engage more, get recognized." We added small, unexpected rewards tied to specific behaviors—things like early access, personalized thank-yous, or even just acknowledging milestones like a customer's one-year anniversary with the brand.
What surprised me wasn't just the lift in repeat purchases, it was how customers started to feel seen. You could tell from the way they responded. It shifted from a transactional relationship to something closer to a community.
From my perspective, personalization at scale doesn't mean knowing everything about a customer. It means showing that you're paying attention in the moments that matter. Even something simple, like referencing a past purchase in a follow-up or tailoring rewards based on how someone interacts with your brand, goes a long way.
If there's one approach I'd recommend, it's to build your loyalty program around recognition, not just rewards. When customers feel recognized for who they are and how they engage—not just what they spend—you create a reason for them to stay that goes beyond discounts.
Remember Stories and Honor Occasions
I've been in fine jewelry for decades, appointment-only, no walk-ins. That structure forced me to learn something most retailers overlook: people remember how they felt, not just what they bought.
The most personal loyalty program I've built isn't a points system -- it's memory. I note details from every consultation: the story behind the purchase, the partner's name, the occasion. When an anniversary is coming up, I reach out personally. That single touch has brought more repeat customers than any discount ever could.
The key is treating the first purchase as the beginning of a relationship, not the end of a transaction. At Washington Diamond, a customer who buys an engagement ring becomes someone I'm thinking about at year one, year five, and when they're ready to redesign a family heirloom. The loyalty builds because the connection feels real -- because it is.
For e-commerce, the translation is straightforward: capture the story at checkout, not just the SKU. A simple "what's the occasion?" field gives you everything you need to follow up in a way that feels human, not automated.
Tom Daube, President, Washington Diamond
Listen First, Then Build Around Customers
I never recommend starting from the business side (from the "loyalty program" mindset). Whether it's a $5M/yr DTC company or a $50M/yr brand, the highest leverage move is to build your loyalty program tactics starting with the customer. That means putting down the pencil on a quick vanilla launch plan.
And don't guess at what customers want (99% of my clients try this at first), but truly find out what moves the needle for them. Meaning: What sort of value will actually move them from one level of commitment to your brand to the next level or beyond? Those are measurable questions that most companies don't bother measuring. Instead, they follow what they see other companies doing.
Take a step back. Take a week to talk to your customers. You can't go wrong listening. And that's the secret to building a program that feels personal. Make it personal.
Yates Jarvis, Founder & Principal, 2 Visions
Let Members Choose Their Benefit Track
A strong way to personalize loyalty is to let customers choose their benefit track at signup and during onboarding. Most loyalty programs feel distant because brands, rather than customers, decide what matters for shoppers. Shoppers become more engaged when they signal their preference at the start of the journey. This approach serves different needs, such as convenience, discovery, or early access, and supports engagement.
Give members two or three reward paths, and allow them to switch over time easily. One path can focus on early access before wider market releases for members. Another path can offer bonus points during key shopping periods and events. Another path can provide planning help and curated recommendations for members.
Mark Bietz, CMO, Halloween Costumes
Surprise with Thoughtful Physical Gifts
Stop relying on points and discounts — they're forgettable. Add a physical element customers don't expect. One jewelry brand we worked with started including personalized silk scarves as accessories with purchases for loyalty members. Not announced, not promoted — just a surprise in the box.
Customers started sharing it unprompted. Repeat purchase rate went up because the experience felt intentional, not transactional. The principle is simple: loyalty programs that only live on a screen compete with every other notification. Something physical and unexpected creates an emotional anchor. The gift doesn't need to be expensive. It needs to feel like someone actually thought about it.
Maria Bakatsiuk, Founder & CMO, Maramio
Use Quizzes to Unlock Intent
To make a loyalty program feel personal, implement interactive content like quizzes or guided decision-making tools to identify a customer's unique intent before they purchase. This allows you to "Evaluate" their specific needs and offer rewards that align with their personal values rather than generic points.
We applied this strategy to Renaissance Limos by defining their brand personality around customer trust and building a digital infrastructure focused on ease and scale. You can achieve this in e-commerce by offering "insider" access or rewards tailored specifically to the results of a brand-aligned preference quiz or sentiment analysis.
Marketing should never operate in isolation; it must align directly with the customer's desire for a personalized experience at every touchpoint. By using these feedback loops, you create a sense of accountability and clarity that helps your brand rise above the noise.
Madeline Jack, Chief Client & Operations Officer, Blink Agency
Grow repeat business with SYMVOLT
A loyalty program works best alongside marketing that keeps customers engaged between purchases. SYMVOLT helps businesses build that through marketing strategy, paid social and conversion-focused websites. For more ideas, read ways to grow e-commerce revenue and how to lower client acquisition costs.
About the author: Nik Aggar is Director of Account Management at SYMVOLT.
